No kid should be forced to choose between sports. There are COUNTLESS examples of athletes who have been good at both. LAZY kids or LAZY coaches preach specialization because it means less work for them. If you truly love a sport you play it. Kids and teams can be good at both if the kids and coaches are willing to put in the work. It's a myth that you have to specialize. Countless studies have proven that there are advantages to playing multiple sports - leading to greater agility and muscular development as you use some different movements and similar movements in each sport, greater camaraderie amongst the student body as there is more likely to be greater cross sport support rather than everyone being in their own clique, there's more excitement going into each season as the kids are moving from one thing to another allowing for fresher mental experiences rather than the same tedious grind every day with months and months before the singular season, kids aren't putting all their hopes and dreams in one source of disappointment/happiness...
Plus, AAU has nothing to do with school ball. It's travel rec league for the majority of kids who play it. And anyone who tries to get a kid to specialize, whether it be basketball or football, isn't thinking of the kid's best interest.