I am referring to 1941 to present since you ask and went to WWII era.....lol.
2023 - Won 20-17
2022 - Lost 6-16 (outperformed Clarkdale but fumbled inside their 5 yd line, they recovered and scored. We moved the ball inside their territory all night but miscues were our demise)
2021 - Lost 0-27 (They kicked our butts)
2012 - Won 45-0
2011 - Won 39-13
I would say that qualifies as routinely outperforming a team.