So I’ll start by saying I think anyone blaming it all on Arnett is tremendously off the mark. The long term issues State is having are FAR more inclusive than just Arnett. Now he does shoulder some blame, but I’d argue it’s more from his defensive recruiting and lack of rotations as DC than his short time in charge of everything.
It feels gross to criticize someone who passed away but I don’t think you can get around it… the Leach era was a massive failure of recruiting in the long haul. I don’t know how you look at the ultra limited roster Lebby inherited and think otherwise. This team is so absurdly portal heavy because they had no choice but to be.
Couple of other things with Arnett vs Lebby:
1. Arnett was hired abruptly amid horrible circumstances. It never felt like he was anything more than an interim. His contract basically said he was an interim (tiny tiny buyout).
2. Arnett was hired/Leach died when State didn’t even have an AD. Lebby was the new AD’s first major hire.
3, Lebby is State’s fourth different head coach since 2018. You can only press the quick eject button on new coaches so many times. State has already maxed that out, in my opinion. It feels like they have no choice but to be patient with Lebby in the name of actually trying to find some semblance of stability for the first time since Mullen left.