Jump to content

Leaderboard

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 02/14/2022 in Posts

  1. The strength of the regions will change year to year. I have no problem with more teams in the playoffs. If a team is weak, they will get beaten. Problem solved. Will the MHSAA make more money? Of course. Will more kids actually get the experience of playing in a playoff? Of course. I'd rather see undeserving teams make the playoffs every year than seeing good teams sitting at home simply because people are opposed to the MHSAA making money. I don't want kids to have to suffer because of what we did "back in our day". Let them play.
    1 point
  2. I've seen MANY #1 seeds beaten by #4 seeds. Just one example this year was Oxford beating South Panola. Some regions just have more talent year in and year out. You see some years where entire regions get swept by another. You can argue that it's diluting the playoffs by having so many make the playoffs, but you could also argue it would be diluting it by taking out some of the better teams in tougher regions.
    1 point
  3. No doubt. And every year in region play Natchez is making 3 and 4 long trips each season. Brookhaven being the shortest drive.
    1 point
  4. You are correct it's a money issue and that's what is driving this. I don't see the gap as a problem that is new or even one that is really causing an issue, all I've said is the association could do things to reduce this if the gap what is driving this. We are both entitled to our opinions and I truly don't have a dog in the race. My thoughts are just mine and I'm not a coach or school administrator who has a vote. It's going to happen after I read the director said it would "increase excitement". That really made me laugh.
    1 point
  5. lol. Looks like we were typing at the same time. I was out of pocket all weekend and watched the SB last night so just now responding.
    1 point
  6. My thought is reduce 6A to 24 teams. The gap won't disappear but is reduced by the same amount as the 7A proposal. 5A could also have 24 teams or keep it at 32. If kept at 32, it just pushes 8 teams down through the remaining 4 classes, so 2 more teams per class. When the cut off points are examined the difference between the bottom and top of classes is small once you are beyond the current 6A proposal. The addition of 2 more schools per class from 4A to 1A won't substantially increase their competition. I am honestly curious why this is an issue now and not years ago. I remember when 5A was first put at 32 teams. I assume there was a comparable gap back then. When 6A was added it was to reduce the spread between the top and bottom of 4A which had some merits, but the problem could have been solved in the same way I am proposing now. I've posted in a couple of threads that yes, I have a strong opinion about it but my thoughts are no more valid than anyone else's, plus my kids are out of high school. I just think it's beyond silly to keep spreading out classifications, shrink regions to 5 teams with 4 playoff teams when I recall the days of 7 or 8 teams (at least in 3A when I was in school) with only the top 2 making the playoffs. That's what decreases the excitement the director was quoted as saying was lacking and was trying to regain with 7 classes. No one can get excited when a 2-8 or 3-7 #4 seed goes on the road to the #1 seed that could be 8-2 or 9-1 for a playoff game that is highly likely to be one sided. In an era of high gas and diesel prices, tickets, concessions, and just getting people to the game, crowds won't be the same unless there is genuine interest from the community. More teams in a class increases competition, more spread out waters it down.
    1 point
  7. And how would they solve the gap problem? I’m genuinely curious as to what your solution would be.
    1 point
×
×
  • Create New...