I completely agree about this being preseason guesswork. Nobody really knows.
No one can reasonably disagree about the talents of Womack, West, Simmons, or Cornbread. Assuming all of these guys play both ways, that's only 2 players on each side of the ball. All I'm saying is that it takes 11 players on each side. Over the past two years, Hartfield was only as good as its running game allowed. Without Reed Jeslowski (that kid is a very, very good player and I will be stunned if he doesn't do exceedingly well at USM) and that o-line, Hartfield will be a fundamentally different team. Have they been able to hit the portal this offseason with the same vigor now that Jenkins isn't there to bankroll everything? We'll see.
Compare the returning production at Hartfield with that of Prep. Prep returns its entire offensive line, its QB, its entire RB room, and its best overall player - Major Quin. It is only replacing a TE and WR, and the replacements for those players are equal to or better than what they had before. Prep has 3 kids committed to play D1, the best QB in the league, and a significant edge in coaching. Where it becomes more interesting is in the ranks of kids who will not play in college, which is the bulk of all high school teams. Who has the better players there? As far as I know, Prep.
Similar things can be said about MRA. MRA has a really good WR group, it picked up JA's top two skill players (and entirely different discussion) at LB/RB (AJ Parker-10.7 100) and all purpose (DJ Watkins-best overall player at JA by a wide margin and a D1 talent), and it too has top notch coaching. It is fair to question how the team will click without White, but I suspect the QB position will be just fine.
The most reasonable assessment of the comparative strength of the teams at this early stage is that they're all equal. But hey - it's the summer; we all miss football; and this is fun. Who cares? Can't wait for mid-August to arrive.